Ruben Amorim Reveals Decision Behind Rashford and Garnacho Exclusion
Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim has shed light on his surprising decision to omit Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho from the squad in Sunday’s dramatic 2-1 derby victory over Manchester City. The move, which raised eyebrows among fans and pundits alike, was described by Amorim as a “simple selection” based on a comprehensive evaluation of player performances and overall professionalism.
Amorim’s Selection Philosophy
In a pre-match interview with Sky Sports, Amorim explained the thought process behind the high-profile exclusions, emphasizing that the decision wasn’t intended to send a message but rather stemmed from his meticulous selection criteria.
“We try to evaluate everything—training performance, game performances, engagement with teammates, pushing their teammates up. Everything is on the line when we analyze and try to choose the players. It is my selection. Simple,” Amorim stated.
He elaborated further: “I pay attention to everything—the way you eat, the way you put your clothes to go to a game. Everything. I make my evaluation and then I decide.”
Amorim was quick to praise Rashford and Garnacho’s efforts in training, dispelling speculation about any underlying fitness concerns. “They are alright. They had training this morning (Sunday) and I was there. They trained really well,” he noted.
Pundits React to Amorim’s Bold Call
The decision sparked immediate debate among football experts, many of whom lauded Amorim’s approach as a sign of strong leadership. Former United captain Roy Keane described it as a pivotal moment in Amorim’s tenure.
“It is a big call. He has obviously seen something he doesn’t like,” Keane said on Sky Sports. “But for those who have watched Manchester United recently, it’s not a big surprise because both players have been poor. He has said ‘enough is enough.’ I like to see it—he has put down a marker.”
Former United striker Dimitar Berbatov drew parallels between Amorim’s decision and Erik ten Hag’s handling of Cristiano Ronaldo last season. “Nobody expected it. There’s a similarity with what Ten Hag did with Ronaldo. But Ronaldo was 36; these players are still in their prime,” Berbatov said.
Michael Owen, another ex-United star, viewed the decision as a throwback to Sir Alex Ferguson’s no-nonsense management style. “I quite like it. I’m a little bit old school. I know someone who was very similar, and that’s Sir Alex Ferguson,” he remarked.
Rashford and Garnacho: Recent Form Under Scrutiny
The exclusion of Rashford and Garnacho from such a crucial fixture has reignited scrutiny of their form and performances this season. Rashford, in particular, has struggled to replicate the prolific form he displayed in the previous campaign, managing just three goals in all competitions. His inconsistent displays have left many questioning his ability to adapt to Amorim’s high-intensity system.
Meanwhile, Garnacho, regarded as one of United’s most promising young talents, has faced criticism for his lack of consistency and discipline. While he has delivered moments of brilliance, including key goals earlier in the season, his overall contributions have been inconsistent.
Amorim’s comments suggest that the decision was about more than just on-field performance. His emphasis on professionalism and attention to detail—down to how players prepare for matches—highlights his commitment to instilling a culture of excellence within the squad.
READ NEXT:
- 10-Man Liverpool Battle Back Twice to Secure Dramatic 2-2 Draw Against Fulham
- Chelsea Edges Brentford 2-1 in Stamford Bridge Thriller
- Manchester Is RED!! Diallo Scores Last-Gasp Winner as United Stun City in Manchester Derby
A Turning Point for Manchester United?
United’s dramatic derby win, secured through late goals from Bruno Fernandes and Amad Diallo, has shifted the focus from the absentees to Amorim’s growing influence at Old Trafford. The victory not only showcased United’s resilience but also reinforced Amorim’s authority as a manager unafraid to make tough decisions.
Pundits believe this moment could mark a turning point in Amorim’s reign. Keane emphasized the importance of the move in setting the tone for the rest of the season. “When you’re a new manager, you have to make your standards clear early on. Amorim’s decision shows he won’t tolerate anything less than 100% commitment,” he said.
Berbatov echoed this sentiment, urging Rashford and Garnacho to respond positively. “The new coach brings new methods, new ways of thinking, and they need to keep up with it. This is a wake-up call for them,” he stated.
What’s Next for Rashford and Garnacho?
Both Rashford and Garnacho face a crucial period in their United careers. While Amorim’s comments suggest the door remains open for their return, it’s clear that earning their places back in the squad will require more than just good performances in training.
For Rashford, the challenge lies in rediscovering the consistency and intensity that made him United’s talisman last season. Garnacho, on the other hand, must balance his natural flair with greater discipline and tactical awareness to fit into Amorim’s system.
The January transfer window looms, and speculation about Rashford’s future has already begun. Former United players, including Keane, have suggested that a fresh start elsewhere could benefit the 27-year-old. However, Rashford’s response to Sunday’s omission—posting a supportive message on social media—indicates his willingness to fight for his place under Amorim.
Amorim’s Vision for Manchester United
Amorim’s decision to drop Rashford and Garnacho underscores his commitment to building a cohesive and disciplined team. His meticulous approach, which considers every aspect of a player’s preparation and attitude, reflects a manager determined to restore United to their former glory.
As United continue their campaign, the fallout from Sunday’s derby will undoubtedly shape the narrative around Amorim’s tenure. For now, his bold call has paid off, with United claiming a morale-boosting victory and sending a clear message: no player is bigger than the team.
